"PTR 2.1 patch notes.: “Rumsey Rum”, “Rumsey Rum Light”, “Rumsey Rum Dark”, “Rumsey Rum Black Label”, “Halaani Whiskey”, “Gordok Green Grog”, “Raptor Punch”, “Stormstout”, “Trogg Ale”, and “Thunderbrew Lager”: The stat bonuses from these

no longer stacks with stamina bonuses from other foods."
In my experience the +stam buff on this drink does not stack with food buffs *at all*, not just +stam food buffs. As a Warlock, when I eat Blackened Basilisk (+23 spell damage, +20 spirit), then drink this, it removes my Well Fed buff. Vice versa, if I drink this, then eat Blackened Basilisk, it removes my Rum (+stam) buff.